UI and usability comments/suggestions/requests
Posted: Mon Oct 04, 2010 6:46 am
I've been using MacDive 2 for a while now, and thought I'd post a few comments about some usability issues I find with the application, as well as some requests. Please note, I LOVE the app, and have been a supporter and user of it since v1.
1. Globally:
1a. Please provide an option to confirm before deleting for gear, gear groups, certifications, sites, etc. It is just too darn easy to accidentally delete something. I have the 'Warn before deleting' option checked in the settings, but that apparently does not apply to these types of items.
1b. With the current 'bubble' UI for gear, certs, sites, etc, so much of the description is/can be cut off. I'd like to be able to see more without having to click. Perhaps a 'mouseover' approach, where mousing over a bubble will cause the bubble to 'grow' and show more information. Mousing out return it to normal size.
1c. After double clicking a bubble and the entry layer is displayed, closing that layer should be simpler. I should be able to click anywhere to hide it, especially white space. But the only way to close it is by clicking another bubble.
2. Certifications section:
2a. Without an image attached to a cert, you have no idea what it is without double clicking the bubble. If no image is attached, have the bubble at least display the 'Type'.
2b. New gear and new sites can be created via the Action drop-down menu, but Certifications have a 'New' button. Why a different UI for creating a Certification? Why not just have a 'New Certification' option in the drop-down menu?
2c. Would love a list display option for certs.
3. Date section in sidebar
3a. In the dates section in the sidebar, 4 date 'smart searches' exist. Any chance these 'smart searches' can be auto-hidden if they have no results?
4. Divers section in sidebar
4a. Normally when adding a new dive, the 'Diver' column is populated by 'New Diver'. What would be great is if I have clicked on an existing diver in the sidebar, selecting 'New Dive' from the file menu would populate that field with the highlighted diver.
That's it for now
Again, thanks for a great application!
1. Globally:
1a. Please provide an option to confirm before deleting for gear, gear groups, certifications, sites, etc. It is just too darn easy to accidentally delete something. I have the 'Warn before deleting' option checked in the settings, but that apparently does not apply to these types of items.
1b. With the current 'bubble' UI for gear, certs, sites, etc, so much of the description is/can be cut off. I'd like to be able to see more without having to click. Perhaps a 'mouseover' approach, where mousing over a bubble will cause the bubble to 'grow' and show more information. Mousing out return it to normal size.
1c. After double clicking a bubble and the entry layer is displayed, closing that layer should be simpler. I should be able to click anywhere to hide it, especially white space. But the only way to close it is by clicking another bubble.
2. Certifications section:
2a. Without an image attached to a cert, you have no idea what it is without double clicking the bubble. If no image is attached, have the bubble at least display the 'Type'.
2b. New gear and new sites can be created via the Action drop-down menu, but Certifications have a 'New' button. Why a different UI for creating a Certification? Why not just have a 'New Certification' option in the drop-down menu?
2c. Would love a list display option for certs.
3. Date section in sidebar
3a. In the dates section in the sidebar, 4 date 'smart searches' exist. Any chance these 'smart searches' can be auto-hidden if they have no results?
4. Divers section in sidebar
4a. Normally when adding a new dive, the 'Diver' column is populated by 'New Diver'. What would be great is if I have clicked on an existing diver in the sidebar, selecting 'New Dive' from the file menu would populate that field with the highlighted diver.
That's it for now
