UDCF Import issues

[GeorgiaCanuck]

I have created a UDCF file that I want to IMPORT into Mac Dive and noticed a few issues that perhaps you can help me with:

1. MD - does not pick up my <o2> and <n2> mix correctly (When I load the file I still get Nitrox Enrichment = 0%)
2. MD - does not parse Country, Location and Site from <place>
3. MD - does not appear to do anything with <tankvolume>, <density> or <altitude>

I have included a sample of the UDCF that I created.

Thanks Cameron

<profile udcf="1">
<units>imperial</units>
<device>
<vendor>Aeris</vendor>
<model>ATMOS AI</model>
</device>
<addinfo>
<persinfo>Cameron David Wright</persinfo>
<serialid>1805</serialid>
</addinfo>
<repgroup>
<dive>
<place>Jeannie's Glory, Bonaire, Netherland Antillies</place>
<date>
<year>2010</year>
<month>6</month>
<day>13</day>
</date>
<time>
<hour>17</hour>
<minute>08</minute>
<second>00</second>
</time>
<surfaceinterval>4200.0</surfaceinterval>
<temperature>83</temperature>
<density>1030.0</density>
<altitude>0</altitude>
<timedepthmode></timedepthmode>
<gases>
<mix>
<mixname>31%</mixname>
<tank>
<tankvolume>80</tankvolume>
<pstart>3030</pstart>
<pend>1264</pend>
</tank>
<o2>0.31</o2>
<n2>0.69</n2>
</mix>
</gases>
<samples>
<switch>31%</switch>
<delta>15</delta>
<t>15</t>
<d>6.0</d>
<t>30</t>
<d>10.0</d>
<t>45</t>
<d>11.0</d>
<t>60</t>
<d>13.0</d>
<t>60</t>
<d>12.0</d>
<t>75</t>
<d>13.0</d>
<t>90</t>
<d>15.0</d>
<t>105</t>
<d>12.0</d>
<t>120</t>
<d>14.0</d>
<t>135</t>
<d>14.0</d>
<t>150</t>
<d>16.0</d>
<t>165</t>
<d>14.0</d>
<t>180</t>
<d>15.0</d>
<t>195</t>
<d>15.0</d>
<t>210</t>
<d>15.0</d>
<t>225</t>
<d>16.0</d>
<t>240</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>255</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>270</t>
<d>14.0</d>
<t>285</t>
<d>16.0</d>
<t>300</t>
<d>15.0</d>
<t>315</t>
<d>17.0</d>
<t>330</t>
<d>16.0</d>
<t>345</t>
<d>16.0</d>
<t>360</t>
<d>16.0</d>
<t>375</t>
<d>17.0</d>
<t>390</t>
<d>15.0</d>
<t>405</t>
<d>16.0</d>
<t>420</t>
<d>17.0</d>
<t>435</t>
<d>16.0</d>
<t>450</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>465</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>480</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>495</t>
<d>20.0</d>
<t>510</t>
<d>19.0</d>
<t>525</t>
<d>20.0</d>
<t>540</t>
<d>20.0</d>
<t>555</t>
<d>20.0</d>
<t>570</t>
<d>21.0</d>
<t>585</t>
<d>21.0</d>
<t>600</t>
<d>22.0</d>
<t>615</t>
<d>22.0</d>
<t>630</t>
<d>22.0</d>
<t>645</t>
<d>23.0</d>
<t>660</t>
<d>24.0</d>
<t>675</t>
<d>25.0</d>
<t>690</t>
<d>24.0</d>
<t>705</t>
<d>23.0</d>
<t>720</t>
<d>24.0</d>
<t>735</t>
<d>25.0</d>
<t>750</t>
<d>25.0</d>
<t>765</t>
<d>25.0</d>
<t>780</t>
<d>25.0</d>
<t>795</t>
<d>27.0</d>
<t>810</t>
<d>27.0</d>
<t>825</t>
<d>28.0</d>
<t>840</t>
<d>24.0</d>
<t>855</t>
<d>25.0</d>
<t>870</t>
<d>23.0</d>
<t>885</t>
<d>23.0</d>
<t>900</t>
<d>22.0</d>
<t>915</t>
<d>22.0</d>
<t>930</t>
<d>20.0</d>
<t>945</t>
<d>20.0</d>
<t>960</t>
<d>22.0</d>
<t>975</t>
<d>23.0</d>
<t>990</t>
<d>25.0</d>
<t>1005</t>
<d>25.0</d>
<t>1020</t>
<d>26.0</d>
<t>1035</t>
<d>28.0</d>
<t>1050</t>
<d>28.0</d>
<t>1065</t>
<d>28.0</d>
<t>1080</t>
<d>30.0</d>
<t>1095</t>
<d>32.0</d>
<t>1110</t>
<d>32.0</d>
<t>1125</t>
<d>32.0</d>
<t>1140</t>
<d>32.0</d>
<t>1155</t>
<d>32.0</d>
<t>1170</t>
<d>31.0</d>
<t>1185</t>
<d>33.0</d>
<t>1200</t>
<d>35.0</d>
<t>1215</t>
<d>34.0</d>
<t>1230</t>
<d>32.0</d>
<alarm>ascent</alarm>
<t>1245</t>
<d>29.0</d>
<t>1260</t>
<d>29.0</d>
<t>1275</t>
<d>28.0</d>
<t>1290</t>
<d>28.0</d>
<t>1305</t>
<d>26.0</d>
<t>1320</t>
<d>26.0</d>
<t>1335</t>
<d>26.0</d>
<t>1350</t>
<d>25.0</d>
<t>1365</t>
<d>25.0</d>
<t>1380</t>
<d>24.0</d>
<t>1395</t>
<d>23.0</d>
<t>1410</t>
<d>21.0</d>
<t>1425</t>
<d>21.0</d>
<t>1440</t>
<d>19.0</d>
<t>1455</t>
<d>19.0</d>
<t>1470</t>
<d>19.0</d>
<t>1485</t>
<d>20.0</d>
<t>1500</t>
<d>22.0</d>
<t>1515</t>
<d>22.0</d>
<t>1530</t>
<d>20.0</d>
<t>1545</t>
<d>19.0</d>
<t>1560</t>
<d>17.0</d>
<t>1575</t>
<d>20.0</d>
<t>1590</t>
<d>20.0</d>
<t>1605</t>
<d>19.0</d>
<t>1620</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>1635</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>1650</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>1665</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>1680</t>
<d>19.0</d>
<t>1695</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>1710</t>
<d>19.0</d>
<t>1725</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>1740</t>
<d>17.0</d>
<t>1755</t>
<d>17.0</d>
<t>1770</t>
<d>17.0</d>
<t>1785</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>1800</t>
<d>17.0</d>
<t>1815</t>
<d>16.0</d>
<t>1830</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>1845</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>1860</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>1875</t>
<d>17.0</d>
<t>1890</t>
<d>16.0</d>
<t>1905</t>
<d>17.0</d>
<t>1920</t>
<d>15.0</d>
<t>1935</t>
<d>15.0</d>
<t>1950</t>
<d>14.0</d>
<t>1965</t>
<d>15.0</d>
<t>1980</t>
<d>14.0</d>
<t>1995</t>
<d>13.0</d>
<t>2010</t>
<d>15.0</d>
<t>2025</t>
<d>13.0</d>
<t>2040</t>
<d>15.0</d>
<t>2055</t>
<d>15.0</d>
<t>2070</t>
<d>18.0</d>
<t>2085</t>
<d>17.0</d>
<t>2100</t>
<d>14.0</d>
<t>2115</t>
<d>15.0</d>
<t>2130</t>
<d>16.0</d>
<t>2145</t>
<d>13.0</d>
<t>2160</t>
<d>14.0</d>
<t>2175</t>
<d>13.0</d>
<t>2190</t>
<d>14.0</d>
<t>2205</t>
<d>14.0</d>
<t>2220</t>
<d>14.0</d>
<t>2235</t>
<d>13.0</d>
<t>2250</t>
<d>14.0</d>
<t>2265</t>
<d>13.0</d>
<t>2280</t>
<d>12.0</d>
<t>2295</t>
<d>12.0</d>
<t>2310</t>
<d>13.0</d>
<t>2325</t>
<d>12.0</d>
<t>2340</t>
<d>12.0</d>
<t>2355</t>
<d>12.0</d>
<t>2370</t>
<d>11.0</d>
<t>2385</t>
<d>10.0</d>
<t>2400</t>
<d>11.0</d>
<t>2415</t>
<d>10.0</d>
<t>2430</t>
<d>10.0</d>
<t>2445</t>
<d>9.0</d>
<t>2460</t>
<d>9.0</d>
<t>2475</t>
<d>8.0</d>
<t>2490</t>
<d>10.0</d>
<t>2505</t>
<d>10.0</d>
<t>2520</t>
<d>9.0</d>
<t>2535</t>
<d>8.0</d>
<t>2550</t>
<d>6.0</d>
<t>2565</t>
<d>5.0</d>
<t>2580</t>
<d>7.0</d>
<t>2595</t>
<d>7.0</d>
<t>2610</t>
<d>4.0</d>
</samples>
</dive>
</repgroup>
</profile>

[nick]

The problem with the place is that there's no separate fields, so you have to attempt to guess what the country/location/site should be. It's a little error prone.

I'll look at the other issues tonight - probably just a couple of bugs.

[GeorgiaCanuck]

Thanks Nick I appreciate it but if my little issues takes away from getting 2.0 released, forget my issues

Cameron

[nick]

1. MD - does not pick up my <o2> and <n2> mix correctly (When I load the file I still get Nitrox Enrichment = 0%)

This is fixed. v2 will correctly read your o2 percentage now.

3. MD - does not appear to do anything with <tankvolume>, <density> or <altitude>

I don't store or do anything with these values yet (except tank volume), so they're just ignored. I'll look at adding them for v2.x but I don't want to change the database at the moment.

As for tanks, they also work slightly differently in v2. We'll see how it goes after that.

Thanks very much for the sample data though, it was very helpful.

[GeorgiaCanuck]

Thanks Nick, If you want more I have 19 Dives in total in UDCF

Cameron

[nick]

Cheers - not necessary though. There's data in the one you gave me and I have plenty of dives I can export to UDCF

[glennv]

Other problems with UDCF import

1. Does not allow for samplerates higher then 1 second. If you specify the <delta> tag as 0.25 (for my Liquivision X1 logs in freedive mode), it rounds it up to 1 second.

2. It ignores <temperature> tag in the samples section for realtime temperature measurements for each depth sample.


--- cut ----
<deltamode></deltamode>
<samples>
<switch>1</switch>
<delta>0.25</delta>
<d>0.0</d>
<temperature>25.8</temperature>
<d>1.1</d>
<temperature>25.8</temperature>
<d>1.7</d>
<temperature>25.8</temperature>
<d>2.3</d>
<temperature>25.8</temperature>

---- etc etc -----

p.s. I can mail you a full UDCF dive with 0.25 samples and temp if you want for debugging.

[nick]

Other problems with UDCF import

1. Does not allow for samplerates higher then 1 second. If you specify the <delta> tag as 0.25 (for my Liquivision X1 logs in freedive mode), it rounds it up to 1 second.

No, it does not. I wasn't aware of any devices using anything more than 1 second so the field is an integer. As per my email, this can be addressed in an update, but it requires a large update as it needs a database change.

2. It ignores <temperature> tag in the samples section for realtime temperature measurements for each depth sample.

This is not supported by UDCF, so it's fair. But, MacDive does actually support it, it's just called "temp" not "temperature". This was added in to make it more flexible, so you can use that.

p.s. I can mail you a full UDCF dive with 0.25 samples and temp if you want for debugging.

Temp not necessary as above, but sure. Again this won't be an immediate update: it does require some reasonably high impact changes to be made to support more more granular sample rates.

[glennv]

No, it does not. I wasn't aware of any devices using anything more than 1 second so the field is an integer. As per my email, this can be addressed in an update, but it requires a large update as it needs a database change.

Aha that is a bummer. Had hoped it was a small bug since the UDCF standard said it was a real. But since not many comps support this level of accuracy yet, it is understandable. For freediving this level of accuracy is a godsend, since otherwise smooth lines now show exactly what you are doing down there. Like pulling the line, equalisation pauses and the ability to count your no-fin strokes. Praying for an update soon..............

This is not supported by UDCF, so it's fair. But, MacDive does actually support it, it's just called "temp" not "temperature". This was added in to make it more flexible, so you can use that.

Aha . I tried <temp> but it does not work. Still ignores it. Can you check please. UDCF attached

I


b.t.w. It "IS" supported by UDCF only not mentioned very clearly.


----
2.40 <temperature> ... </temperature> (optional)

The lowest water temperature during dive, if known. If unknown the element <temperature> is dropped.

Stands inside the < dive> section after the < surfaceinterval> statement and before < density>. The temperature is given as a real number with one digit after the decimal point.

Example:

<!-- lowest water temperature 12 degrees Celsius -->
<temperature>12.0</temperature>

Alternatively this tag can be used in the samples-section to indicate the temperature of the actual sample.

-------------------------

[nick]

Alternatively this tag can be used in the samples-section to indicate the temperature of the actual sample.

Oh, I totally missed that.

Edit: I see why temp wasn't working for you. I'd actually set it as an attribute of the sample (much easier to parse). "temperature" is now supported as per your sample file, and the schema. I've left temp as an attribute for Rob's sake.